Third-generation Apple TV 4K review: unrivaled strength at a significantly lower cost

Apple has had a successful year, introducing brand-new models of the majority of its products, including the iPhone 14 models, the new M2 MacBooks and iPads, and more. On November 4th, a brand-new Apple TV 4K streaming gadget will be released, with a price increase to match.

With prices starting at just $129, the third-generation Apple TV 4K is $50 less expensive than the previous model. But it's also 30% more power-efficient, 30% smaller, and faster owing to the A15 Bionic chip. It supports HDR10+, Dolby Vision, and Atmos for streaming video with sharp contrast.

Other specialist reviews

The performance enhancements of the Apple TV 4K were fairly obvious, especially when switching programs, but critics remarked that there isn't much else that can actually benefit from it aside from gaming

TechCrunch's Darrell Etherington:

If you have a 2021 Apple TV 4K, which I do, you probably aren't feeling the pinch in terms of performance. In fact, I still have a first-generation Apple TV 4K in active use, and despite it now being six years old, I'd be hard-pressed to tell the difference between it and my 2021 Apple TV in a blind test.

That said, the 2022 Apple TV 4K does seem to generally make things snappier when it comes to navigating between the Home Screen and apps, and even potentially within apps as well. It also definitely offers a boost when it comes to using the Apple TV as a gaming device, helping it keep up with the most graphically-demanding Arcade and App Store titles available. With expanded controller support via the most recent tvOS update, the Apple TV is a better gaming console than ever combined with the A15's performance prowess.

However, CNET's Eli Blumenthal found the Apple TV 4K's gaming experience to be unsatisfactory and highlighted that the A15 Bionic chip is still unable to make the Apple TV competitive with gaming consoles.:

NBA 2K23 loaded quickly, and the game finally has commentary which brings some console-like quality that was lacking in earlier editions, but that's where the similarity ends. In my few games, the title looks and feels a bit slower than the console version. Even with an Xbox controller paired to the Apple TV 4K, there is no direct passing and animations lack the fluidity and sharpness of the game on Xbox One, let alone Xbox Series S/X.

Face models are fine, but lack detail in players' tattoos like D'Angelo Russell and Marcus Smart. Standard basketball game staples like instant replays and quick or batch substitutions also remain absent as do 2K23 game modes like The City.

Gameloft's Asphalt 8 Plus similarly loaded quickly and played fine using the Apple TV's included Siri Remote. But there isn't ray-tracing or other modern graphical improvements that would make anyone confuse this title for a PlayStation 5 or Xbox Series S/X game.

All told, there doesn't appear to be anything extra that the A15 Bionic brings to gaming on Apple TV 4K...

Chris Welch of The Verge stated that although the new Siri Remote's USB-C charging connector is a good addition, there is still a lot more that the remote can do.:

Other than ditching Lightning for USB-C, the included Siri Remote is identical to the prior generation. This is largely positive: it's ergonomic and easy to use, and once you get down the clickpad's rotational gesture for quickly scrubbing through a movie or show, you'll rarely bother with the old less efficient way of fast-forwarding and rewinding. I do badly wish that Apple had included a U1 chip in the new remote that would've made it easy to hunt down with precision using a nearby iPhone. Failing that, even a built-in speaker would've been nice for a "Siri, find my remote" command. This remote isn't as easy to lose as the previous stupidly thin version, but it still happens to the best of us. You can add backlighting and a raised nub on the play / pause button (making it easier to find by feel) to my wish list for the next iteration of the Siri Remote.


 

Comments